Tuesday, February 5, 2008

creative class dismissed

But first, read this article called, “Creative Class, Dismissed.” about a teacher and her efforts to teach Rousseau. In a short blog post, summarize what Rousseau seems to be saying according to the teacher and how her students react to his argument. Then, compare and contrast that with your understanding of “The Creed of the Priest of Savoy” (Book 4 — scroll down to section 943).

"Rousseau has an overarching thesis that considers people to be good by nature but corrupted by society. My students like that, since it reassures them that it's not entirely their fault every time they do something bad, but rather that some larger social force "made me do it." And Rousseau articulates the longings in my students for more of a reason to live than competing for who's the best looking and smartest, or who ends up with the most toys."
The teacher is statig that Rousseau is explaining human fallicy by showing societies pressure upon them creating and adding to human fallicies.

"Many students tell me that reading Rousseau makes them conscious of the fact that ineluctably fascinating human wrongdoing almost always trumps the dullness of virtue, and that people who cheerily trumpet art (especially that which showcases bad behavior as entertainment) are blind to both art's power and its peril. One of my former seminar members recently wrote me that he was glad he'd read Letter to d'Alembert because he'd learned from it that, in the end, he prefers being miserable and loving art to his earlier childhood state of being happy and ignorant of it. This student was clear, at least: He was choosing art over virtue."
Students feel that they are more aware of their wrongdoings and the actions they commit against the arts.

"Whatever their ultimate opinions, I like to think Rousseau's essay humbles my students just a little, in just the right way, and at just the right moment in their lives. It reminds them that the kind of moral person they are becoming will never, ever hinge on the fact that they're getting a college degree. "
The teacher feels that students are more humbly aware of themselves and their actions from Rousseau's writing.

My understanding of "creed of priest Savvoy" is that the teacher in book 4 is telling students to have conscine on their actions of morality. Rousseaus work deals more with the arts and nature that the creed foes. Both do, however deal with the issue of morality and how best to act upon it.

No comments: